Amara Cay Resort
Nestled between the wilderness of Everglades National Park and North America's only coral barrier reef, Islamorada was destined to become the Sport Fishing Capital of the World. Guest can take an eco-tour to explore coral formations, tropical fish and dolphin pods. The truly adventurous can even go by canoe or kayak to the remote Indian Key Historic State Park. Miami International Airport is about 133 km away. The family-friendly hotel offers a fittingly luxurious setting to take in this breathtaking resort destination. The resort has a broad range of services and amenities to make any guest's stay exceptional. The premises are air-conditioned and guests are welcomed in a lobby. There is a cloakroom, a bar and a restaurant available for guests. Further amenities include conference facilities and room service. All accommodation units are fully-equipped as standard.

Hotel Facilities

General

  • Number of bars/lounges: 3
  • Number of poolside bars: 1
  • Number of restaurants: 2

Activities

  • Hiking/biking trails nearby
  • Fitness facilities

Food & Drink

  • Television in common areas
  • Breakfast available (surcharge)
  • Snack bar/deli

Pools and wellness

  • Pool umbrellas
  • Number of outdoor pools: 1
  • Pool sun loungers

Front-desk/reception area services

  • Luggage storage
  • 24-hour front desk

Shared spaces

  • Garden
  • Terrace

Cleaning services

  • Laundry facilities

Business facilities

  • Number of meeting rooms: 1

Shops

  • Gift shops or newsstand

Other facilities

  • Designated smoking areas
  • Wedding services
  • On private beach
  • Multilingual staff
  • Lift

Location

Islamorada, Florida, United States of America

Address: 80001 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, United States of America

Reviews

4.3/ 5Very goodAverage review rating
Browse reviews by provider:
5 reviewsSorted by: Newest
Steven ONov 2026
5.0/ 5

“Excellent”

I've been there about 8 times klolie at front desk did a amazing job for us thank you see you in the summer great place and clean as it could be thank you

  • Stayed in Nov 2026
William CNov 2026
5.0/ 5

“Relaxing and affordable. Todd at the bar was great”

Todd at the bar was great! Very helpful and did a great job.

  • Stayed in Nov 2026
Jarni PNov 2026
5.0/ 5

“Fun!”

MK was very nice and helpful. Bike ride was awesome!

  • Stayed in Nov 2026
Cheryl WNov 2026
5.0/ 5

“Amara Cay Won Us Over”

We’ve passed Amara Cay many times over the years, and after our first stay, we’re wondering why we waited so long! The location was perfect, the views were beautiful, and everyone we met—especially the staff—couldn’t have been friendlier. A special shoutout to Beaubara and Vernene for making our stay even more memorable! We also loved how dog-friendly it was. Our Tristan felt just as welcome as we did, which made the trip even more special. Between the live music, happy hours, and fantastic food, there was so much to enjoy. Honestly, it’s one of the best places to eat on the island. Such a welcoming, relaxing place for a getaway. We’ll definitely be back!

  • Stayed in Oct 2026
Wendy GOct 2026
5.0/ 5

“Kayaking at Amara Cay!”

MK was so great getting us out on the kayaks even when it was a bit windy - a great experience!

  • Stayed in Oct 2026
How Tripadvisor collects reviews
Skip past other hotels

Other Hotels in United States of America

YOTEL New York Times Square

YOTEL New York Times Square

4.0Good(25,000+)

United States of America, New York City

Flight & Hotel / 7 nights / Room Only

from£765pp
Plus local fees of £131 pp. Total holiday £896 pp.
ATOL Protected
ROW NYC

ROW NYC

3.8Good(10,000+)

United States of America, New York City

Flight & Hotel / 7 nights / Room Only

from£785pp
Plus local fees of £135 pp. Total holiday £920 pp.
ATOL Protected
Floridays Resort Orlando

Floridays Resort Orlando

4.4Very good(25,000+)

United States of America, Orlando

Flight & Hotel / 6 nights / Self-Catering

from£655pp
ATOL Protected
Caesars Palace

Caesars Palace

4.5Excellent(100,000+)

United States of America, Las Vegas

Flight & Hotel / 5 nights / Room Only

from£1,065pp
Plus local fees of £116 pp. Total holiday £1,181 pp.
ATOL Protected
Empire Hotel

Empire Hotel

3.8Good(10,000+)

United States of America, New York City

Flight & Hotel / 7 nights / Room Only

from£945pp
Plus local fees of £60 pp. Total holiday £1,005 pp.
ATOL Protected
Park Central Hotel New York

Park Central Hotel New York

3.9Good(10,000+)

United States of America, New York City

Flight & Hotel / 7 nights / Room Only

from£885pp
Plus local fees of £126 pp. Total holiday £1,011 pp.
ATOL Protected
Hotel Edison Times Square

Hotel Edison Times Square

4.1Very good(10,000+)

United States of America, New York City

Flight & Hotel / 7 nights / Room Only

from£850pp
Plus local fees of £125 pp. Total holiday £975 pp.
ATOL Protected
NEW YORKER BY LOTTE HOTELS

NEW YORKER BY LOTTE HOTELS

4.0Good(10,000+)

United States of America, New York City

Flight & Hotel / 7 nights / Room Only

from£860pp
Plus local fees of £119 pp. Total holiday £979 pp.
ATOL Protected
Hard Rock Hotel New York - Partner of ALL Accor

Hard Rock Hotel New York - Partner of ALL Accor

4.6Excellent(5,000+)

United States of America, New York City

Flight & Hotel / 5 nights / Room Only

from£1,190pp
Plus local fees of £86 pp. Total holiday £1,276 pp.
ATOL Protected
Universal's Endless Summer Resort - Dockside Inn and Suites

Universal's Endless Summer Resort - Dockside Inn and Suites

4.4Very good(25,000+)

United States of America, Orlando

Flight & Hotel / 7 nights / Room Only

from£720pp
ATOL Protected
1 of 0

Other hotels in Florida